You are here

Lead Stories

Lead Stories

Supreme Court Says California Cannot Require Filing of Schedule B

Court says requirement violates First Amendment right to freedom of association of donors
After nearly a decade of litigation over whether states may require charities seeking to register to solicit charitable contributions to file a complete copy of their Form 990 tax information return, including an unredacted Schedule B containing the names of significant donors, the 6-3 conservative majority of the U.S. Supreme Court has held that the requirement violates the donors’ First Amendment right of association, a question that is “not even close” according to two of the Justices. In so holding, according to the three dissenting justices, the Court has “discard[ed] its decades-long requirement” that the plaintiffs must plead and prove that disclosure will likely expose them to...

National Rifle Association Fails in Attempt To Use Bankruptcy to Move to Texas

Court dismisses case, saying it was not filed in good faith and was an effort to avoid New York regulatory action
The National Rifle Association, sued last summer by the Attorney General of New York seeking to dissolve the organization and recover large sums from top officials for breach of fiduciary duty, has failed in an effort to use bankruptcy as a vehicle to move the corporation to Texas. A Bankruptcy Court in the Northern District of Texas has ruled that the case was not filed in good faith. The Court agreed with the Attorney General of New York that the NRA was attempting to use the bankruptcy proceeding to address a regulatory enforcement problem, not a financial one. Because it was not filed “for a purpose intended or sanctioned by the Bankruptcy Code,” the Court said, it was not filed in good...

DAF Sponsor Not Liable For Damages in Liquidating Stock

Court finds Fidelity Gift Fund did not breach contract and was not liable for negligence in sale of gift stock
In a long-anticipated ruling, Fidelity Investments Charitable Gift Fund has been found not liable to the donors to a donor advised fund who claimed that they were damaged significantly when Fidelity sold all 1.9 million donated shares of a thinly-traded company in the last 2.5 hours of trading of the last day of trading in December 2017. A magistrate judge in a Federal District Court in California has dismissed all of the donors’ claims. Malcolm and Emily Fairbairn founded a hedge fund where they managed over $3 billion. In 2017, because of a change in the tax law, they recognized about $250 million of off-shore income and decided to make a large charitable contribution to offset some of...

Bankruptcy Stays Suit Against Officeholder of Corporation Sole

Because law is “arcane” and “murky,” Court refuses to impose sanctions on plaintiff who files new case
The Bankruptcy Code provides that all pending or potential claims against the debtor are automatically stayed and may not be pursued when the debtor formally files for bankruptcy protection. But the law also provides that cases are not stayed against non-debtors, including the individual officers of a bankrupt organization. The officers may be sued in their individual capacity except in narrow and unusual circumstances, such as when there is such an identity between the debtor and the third party defendant that the debtor may be said to be the real party defendant and a judgment against the third party defendant will in effect be a judgment against the debtor. The issue of whether the...

Who Owns Rights to Event Photos Taken By Volunteer for Nonprofit?

Court says pictures are owned by photographer and are not ‘works for hire’ controlled by group
The Military Sexual Trauma Movement was formed in 2018 as a 501(c)(4) organization to help survivors of military sexual trauma and other discrimination. Its leadership was all volunteers and it had no paid employees. In September, 2019, it planned several days of demonstrations and activities in Washington, D.C. to promote its agenda. At one unplanned event outside the home of the Commandant of the Marine Corps, the founder of the group made some comments that some other members considered so “abusive and confrontational” that the other members resigned from the group. They simultaneously withdrew their consent for the group to use their names and any photos of themselves “in any fashion”...

Violation of Donor Bill of Rights Insufficient to Justify Fraud Charge

Court dismisses claims against NRA Foundation brought by donors who said funds were not used for mission
Fundraisers for charity frequently cite the Donor Bill of Rights , created by the Association of Fundraising Professionals and other professional fundraising organizations, as evidence of the charity’s good stewardship of charitable contributions. But what happens when a disgruntled donor claims the charity failed to live up to the high ideals it espoused? A federal District Court in Tennessee has held that pointing to the Donor Bill of Rights on the website of the NRA Foundation, the charitable fundraising arm of the National Rifle Association, is not sufficient to meet the plausible pleading requirement of federal law and prevent dismissal of the donors’ claim that they suffered damages...

Pages

Subscribe to Lead Stories

Sign-up for our weekly Q&A; get a free report on electioneering