Lead Stories

New Members May Take Over Nonprofit By Paying Dues and Calling Meeting

Court says bylaws contemplate membership upon payment and new members may call special meeting to replace board

A largely dormant nonprofit corporation has been taken over by 60 new members who paid their $25 annual dues, called a special meeting of members, voted out the old board of directors and replaced them with a new slate of their own choosing. 

Former Directors Lack Standing For Declaratory Action to Contest Election

Federal court dismisses complaint when plaintiffs failed to file derivative action or allege current or future personal harm

A suit contesting an election at the Association of Philippine Physicians in America Foundation has been dismissed by a federal district court in Kentucky when the plaintiffs did not follow the procedures to bring a derivative action or allege current or future personal harm.  (Pagtakhan-So v. Cueto, E.D. KY, No. 5:14-370, 2/16/16.

Charges Dropped When Defendants Constructively Denied Counsel Before Grand Jury

University’s counsel could not adequately represent employees and was incompetent to testify about communications with them

Counsel for Penn State University, who purported to represent university employees at a grand jury investigation into the Jerry Sandusky sexual abuse scandal, could not provide adequate counsel to them as individuals and was incompetent to testify as to her communications with them, an appellate court in Pennsylvania has ruled.

Bank Trustee Not Liable For Delay in Distributing Funds

Value of distributions to charities dropped $11 million between event trigging distribution and delivery of cash

A bank trustee that took a little more than two months to distribute trust funds to charities during the precipitous drop in stock prices in late 2008 is not liable for a breach of fiduciary duty under the circumstances of the case, an appellate court in California has affirmed.  (Estate of Gilliland, Hi-Desert Memorial Hospital v. Union Bank of California, Ct. of App. CA, Second Dist., Div.

School Can’t Temporarily Drop Residential, High School Programs

Court denies request by trustees of Girard College to permit deviation from trust because of decline in financial status

Trustees of Girard College, a free elementary and secondary school for disadvantaged youth in Philadelphia, have been denied a request to eliminate their residential and high school programs temporarily in order to rebuild their reserves to assure the long-term viability of their programs.  The Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court has affirmed an Orphans’ Court decision denying the request.  (Estate of Stephen Girard, No. 2254 C.D. 2014, 1/21/16.