Lead Stories

Unsigned Gift Pledge Enforceable Against Donor’s Estate

Temple’s detrimental reliance in capital campaign converts commitment to level of enforceable pledge

A decedent’s estate properly paid a $246,000 claim to a Jewish synagogue when the Temple relied on the unsigned pledge to encourage others to participate in its campaign for a new building and endowment, the Supreme Court of Alabama has ruled.  The fact that one of the co-executors was a member of the Temple and on one of its committees did not invalidate the payment.  (Ruttenberg v. Friedman, No. 1090600, 5/11/12.)

Boy Scouts Lose Efforts To Protect Abuse Files

Oregon court permits release of “ineligible volunteer” files, Idaho court orders production of “perversion” records for discovery

The Boy Scouts of America has recently lost two efforts to keep confidential its internal records of volunteers accused of sexual abuse. Several decades of records were, or could be, used to support damage claims by men seeking to impose liability on the Scouts for abuse.

The Oregon Supreme Court has affirmed a trial court decision to open redacted files to the media upon the conclusion of a case in which a jury returned a verdict against the Scouts for $1.4 million in compensatory damages and $18 million in punitives.

Bankruptcy Court Dismisses Case When Issue Is Control of Nonprofit

May “members” of corporation approve acquisition when board of directors rejects transaction?

A bankruptcy court in western Pennsylvania has dismissed a bankruptcy proceeding it found was not filed in good faith by directors of a nonprofit corporation when the corporation was not insolvent and the board was fighting for control of the organization in a pending state court proceeding.  (In Re: Laurel Highlands Foundation, Inc., Debtor, Bkrptcy Ct. W.D. PA, No. 12-22558, 6/12/12.)

Does Employee Have Expectation of Privacy In “Friend”-Protected Facebook Page?

Court allows union leader to pursue case when employer coerced another employee to reveal posting

The federal District Court of New Jersey has allowed a former employee to sue her nonprofit employer for invasion of privacy for allegedly coercing another employee, who was her “friend” on Facebook, to reveal a Facebook posting to the employer who was not a friend and had no access to the posting.  (Ehling v. Monmouth-Ocean County Hospital Service Corp., No. 2:11-cv-03305, 5/30/12.)

Charity May Sue Director For Breach of Duty on Contract

Arbitration clause in construction contract does not prevent separate fiduciary duty claim in court

A nonprofit organization that enters into a construction contract with a company owned by one of its directors may bring a separate breach of fiduciary duty claim against the director/owner when things go bad and is not limited to arbitration by the arbitration clause in the construction contract, an appellate court in Pennsylvania has held. (Elwyn v. DeLuca, Superior Ct., PA, No. 1519 EDA 2011, 7/2/12.)